This Stephen Flaherty & Lynn Ahrens musical, their second, was a surprise hit in the West End in 1994 at the then Royalty, now Peacock, Theatre, winning the Olivier Award for Best Musical. It’s only London revival was a brief visit to Hackney Empire at the end of a short tour in 2009. This new production follows a hugely successful revival on Broadway six years ago. It wasn’t tropical on Saturday, but it was a beautiful evening in this unique venue. The first of my summer traditions this year.
The show is based on a Caribbean set novel which is itself based on Hans Christian Andersen’s fairytale The Little Mermaid, though I’m afraid that I struggled to make the connection. It works on a number of levels, starting in present day Haiti where we, the audience, are the tourists and there’s a hint of military oppression. A couple tell their daughters the story of Ti Moune and we enter that story.
Ti Moune is an orphan saved from the floods by the gods and taken in by Mama Euralie and Tonton Julian. When she is older she in turn saves Daniel, one of the French upper class colonists, from a car crash and falls in love with him. Tonton Julian fetches Daniel’s people and we learn he is the result of an affair between Armand, a ‘grands homme’ and a local girl. Though Ti Moune’s love is requited, it is never going to lead anywhere, which we realise when we move to the other side of the island, and another world, with the grands homme. Daniel has been promised to Andrea since he was a child.
I struggled with the first part of the show, before it got dark, because the rather incongruous set of a wooden pit and twenty wooden towers by Georgia Lowe didn’t transport you to the Caribbean as much as the theatre’s natural setting would have done; the gentle breeze in the trees and the birdsong did more. As it darkened and we moved to the hotel on the other side of the island it worked better. The excellent costumes by Melissa Simon-Hartman did something to compensate for the set, but I still felt Ola Ince’s production was a missed opportunity of using what nature had give this theatre, as they did so spectacularly with Into The Woods. It often felt like a concert more than a show, like Jesus Christ Superstar and Evita here before it.
As well as being a ‘fairytale’, the show covers issues such as colonialism, race and class. It’s strength is Flaherty’s excellent score, particularly given it was his second show, better than I remembered, with orchestrations here that seemed to emphasise percussion, particularly steel drums and give it a real Caribbean feel. The musical standards under MD Chris Poon were high and the quality of the vocals were exceptional, with Danielle Brooks shining brightly in the role of Ti Moune and a uniformly excellent supporting cast.
Flaherty & Ahrens have produced more satisfying shows – Ragtime and Dessa Rose – but this is better than I remembered, despite a disappointing use of this lovely space.